· Help
Asia Pacific
Rampant Fraud Threat to China's Brisk Ascent
Published: October 6, 2010
·
Reprints
BEIJING — No one disputes Zhang Wuben's talents as a salesman. Through television shows, DVDs and a best-selling book, he convinced millions of people that raw eggplant and immense quantities of mung beans could cure lupus, diabetes, depression and cancer.
Du Bin for The New York Times
Fang Shimin, also known by his pen name, Fang Zhouzi, exposes academic fakery in China on his Web site, New Threads.
For $450, seriously ill patients could buy a 10-minute consultation and a prescription — except Mr. Zhang, one of the most popular practitioners of traditional Chinese medicine, was booked through 2012.
But when the price of mung beans skyrocketed this spring, Chinese journalists began digging deeper. They learned that contrary to his claims, Mr. Zhang, 47, was not from a long line of doctors (his father was a weaver). Nor did he earn a degree from Beijing Medical University (his only formal education, it turned out, was the brief correspondence course he took after losing his job at a textile mill).
The exposure of Mr. Zhang's faked credentials provoked a fresh round of hand-wringing over what many scholars and Chinese complain are the dishonest practices that permeate society, including students who cheat on college entrance exams, scholars who promote fake or unoriginal research, and dairy companies that sell poisoned milk to infants.
The most recent string of revelations has been bracing. After a plane crash in August killed 42 people in northeast China, officials discovered that 100 pilots who worked for the airline's parent company had falsified their flying histories. Then there was the padded résumé of Tang Jun, the millionaire former head of Microsoft China and something of a national hero, who falsely claimed to have received a doctorate from the California Institute of Technology.
Few countries are immune to high-profile frauds. Illegal doping in sports and malfeasance on Wall Street are running scandals in the United States. But in China, fakery in one area in particular — education and scientific research — is pervasive enough that many here worry it could make it harder for the country to climb the next rung on the economic ladder.
A Lack of Integrity
China devotes significant resources to building a world-class education system and pioneering research in competitive industries and sciences, and has had notable successes in network computing, clean energy, and military technology. But a lack of integrity among researchers is hindering China's potential and harming collaboration between Chinese scholars and their international counterparts, scholars in China and abroad say.
"If we don't change our ways, we will be excluded from the global academic community," said Zhang Ming, a professor of international relations at Renmin University in Beijing. "We need to focus on seeking truth, not serving the agenda of some bureaucrat or satisfying the desire for personal profit."
Pressure on scholars by administrators of state-run universities to earn journal citations — a measure of innovation — has produced a deluge of plagiarized or fabricated research. In December, a British journal that specializes in crystal formations announced that it was withdrawing more than 70 papers by Chinese authors whose research was of questionable originality or rigor.
In an editorial published earlier this year, The Lancet, the British medical journal, warned that faked or plagiarized research posed a threat to President Hu Jintao's vow to make China a "research superpower" by 2020.
"Clearly, China's government needs to take this episode as a cue to reinvigorate standards for teaching research ethics and for the conduct of the research itself," the editorial said. Last month a collection of scientific journals published by Zhejiang University in Hangzhou reignited the firestorm by publicizing results from a 20-month experiment with software that detects plagiarism. The software, called CrossCheck, rejected nearly a third of all submissions on suspicion that the content was pirated from previously published research. In some cases, more than 80 percent of a paper's content was deemed unoriginal.
The journals' editor, Zhang Yuehong, emphasized that not all the flawed papers originated in China, although she declined to reveal the breakdown of submissions. "Some were from South Korea, India and Iran," she said.
The journals, which specialize in medicine, physics, engineering and computer science, were the first in China to use the software. For the moment they are the only ones to do so, Ms. Zhang said.
Plagiarism and Fakery
Her findings are not surprising if one considers the results of a recent government study in which a third of the 6,000 scientists at six of the nation's top institutions admitted they had engaged in plagiarism or the outright fabrication of research data. In another study of 32,000 scientists last summer by the China Association for Science and Technology, more than 55 percent said they knew someone guilty of academic fraud.
Fang Shimin, a muckraking writer who has become a well-known advocate for academic integrity, said the problem started with the state-run university system, where politically appointed bureaucrats have little expertise in the fields they oversee. Because competition for grants, housing perks and career advancement is so intense, officials base their decisions on the number of papers published.
"Even fake papers count because nobody actually reads them," said Mr. Fang, who is more widely known by his pen name, Fang Zhouzi, and whose Web site, New Threads, has exposed more than 900 instances of fakery, some involving university presidents and nationally lionized researchers.
Next Page »
Li Bibo and Zhang Jing contributed research.
This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:
Correction: October 7, 2010
An earlier version of this article incorrectly named a member of the Politburo. She is Liu Yandong, not Liu Dongdong. An earlier version of this article also gave an incorrect name for a school where Xiao Chuanguo's appointment was blocked. Dr Xiao was blocked from an appointment to the Chinese Academy of Sciences, not the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.
A version of this article appeared in print on October 7, 2010, on page A1 of the New York edition.
· Colleges and Universities Get E-Mail Alerts
· Cheating Get E-Mail Alerts
· Frauds and Swindling Get E-Mail Alerts
2. Readers' Recipes: The Potluck
3. Spaghetti Tacos: Silly Enough for Young Eaters
4. Op-Ed Contributor: How Not to Fight Colds
5. Rampant Fraud Threat to China's Brisk Ascent
6. At Flagging Tribune, Tales of a Bankrupt Culture
7. Op-Ed Contributor: The Seat Not Taken
8. The Stone: The Spoils of Happiness
9. Maureen Dowd: Onward Christian Moguls
10. Nicholas D. Kristof: Trifecta of Torment
Go to Complete List »
2.At Sam Zell's Tribune, Tales of a Bankrupt Culture
3.Obama, Seeking Votes, Makes Appeal to Liberals
4.Honeybee Killer Found by Army and Entomologists
5.The Terminator vs. Big Oil
6.Health Care Law's Uneven Path to Better Insurance
7.The Spaghetti Taco, la 'iCarly'
8.Poll: Hispanics May Skip Midterms Over Immigration
9.A Push to Ban Soda Purchases With Food Stamps
10.Gunmen Attack More NATO Supply Trucks in Pakistan
Go to Complete List »
2.modern love
3.education
4.october 3, 2010
5.nobel prize
6.brazil
7.immigration
8.september 5, 2010
9.india
10.contador
Go to Complete List »
2.Gail Collins: Connecticut on the Ropes
3.At Yale, Anger Over Tactics Used in Raid of Off-Campus Party
4.Waivers Aim at Talk of Dropping Health Coverage
5.Op-Ed Contributor: The Seat Not Taken
6.Vargas Llosa Is Awarded Nobel Prize in Literature
7.Nicholas D. Kristof: Trifecta of Torment
8.Rampant Fraud Threat to China's Brisk Ascent
9.Guarded Pals In a Critical TV Rivalry
10.New York Asks to Bar Use of Food Stamps to Buy Sodas
Follow The New York Times on Twitter
Watch today's top videos
See the news in the making. Watch TimesCast, a daily news video.
· U.S.
· N.Y. / Region
· Business
· Technology
· Science
· Health
· Sports
· Opinion
· Arts
· Style
· Travel
· Jobs
· Real Estate
· Autos
· Back to Top
· Copyright 2010 The New York Times Company
· Terms of Service
· Search
· Corrections
· RSS
· First Look
· Help
· Contact Us
· Work for Us
· Advertise
· Site Map
No comments:
Post a Comment