Wednesday, April 3, 2013

Re: USA Africa Dialogue Series - Henry Louis Gates is Wrong about African Involvement in the Slave Trade

Toyin,

I will advise again that you research the Osu agbara phenomenon deeply
before taking position. Your lack of deep research on this issue
manifests in such positions like; the servants of gods (Osu agbaras),
who must carry sacrifices to the inner sanctums of shrines (holy of
holies), for instance, can be described as "contaminated/compromised
(cursed) humanity", when even those who offer these sacrifices must
first sanctify themselves before presenting these offerings. For one
to even invoke the names of these gods in "iju ogu" for instance, one
must attain a high level of sanctity.

You exhibited further lack of deep understanding of the Osu agbara
phenomenon when for instance, you maintained that an Osu agbara cannot
opt out of his/her status.

You should also re-examine your research method in this matter.

I am done with this thread.

CAO.


On 3 Apr, 15:06, OLUWATOYIN ADEPOJU <tva...@gmail.com> wrote:
> *Apologies. Reposting with addition*
>
>  *   Response to Chidi *
>
>        *Paradox of Spiritual Dedication and Service as Social Stigma in the
> Osu System *
>
> 1. *Spiritual Dedicand and Social Stigmatite [neologisms] *
>
> '(1) Can servants of gods in Igboland be regarded as contaminated/
>
> compromised humanity?
> (2) Can Chukwu's(God's) representatives on earth; amadioha and others
> condone being served by contaminated/compromised humanity?'
> Chidi
>
> The answer of collective Igbo cultural memory to this question is  YES.
>
> The logic being that they are understood as contaminated in a way that  is
> dangerous to other humans but is a consequence of their dedication to the
> deity.
>
> Francis Onwubuariri addresses this paradox in 'Appraising the Osu Caste
> System in Igboland<http://www.frasouzu.com/Issues%20and%20Papers/Onwubuariri%20Francis.htm>
> '
>
> '...they can be given the sacred place of priest, they are still seen as
> priests without power and prestige by the freeborn because they do not and
> cannot command the respect or attract the admiration of the freeborns due
> to their Osu stigma in the sight of the freeborns due to the fact that they
> see themselves as inferior beings.'
> ......
> According to M. M. Green talking about making an Osu priest in his Book
> Igbo Village Affairs, he made the point that "The Osu people looked up as
> horrible and holy by the society do not necessarily make them into people
> of authority, because of their anomalous position in some society, but it
> does not mean that they are or may be a part of the mechanism whereby law
> and order are preserved (1978, 20).
> ....
>
> 2. *Brutal and Once Pervasive Discrimination *
>
> '(3)What are the manifestations of  this Contamination(curse) in the Igbo
> belief system?'
>
> It has been held that relating with Osu is harmful.
>
> People refuse to marry Osu so that cures do not enter into their family and
> so they too dont become Osu.
>
> It has been stated that Osu gives off a bad smell on account of the effect
> of the 'juju' that owns them.
>
> Francis Onwubuariri lists various forms of anti-osu discrimination-
>
> 1. *Marriage* between osu and diala or freeborn, a taboo. Sexual relations
> taboo. Any infringement  makes the offending freeborn osu.
>
> The Facebook groups against the Osu sysyenm describe this as still very
> active among Igbos in Nigeria.
>
> 2.* Birth and Death *
>
> From birth to death, the Diala do not ever dare to rejoice over or
> celebrate the arrival of a new born baby delivered by an Osu as they do not
> sympathize with or lament over mishaps on them" (64).
>
> Besides, it is said accordingly that in the Igbo days of Yore, that at the
> death of an Osu, the Diala do not participate in the digging of ground as
> well as taking part in any other burial rites likewise the Osus. The Osus
> are not allowed to be buried around the places where the freeborn were
> buried.
> One of the reasons for this hostility towards the Osus by the freeborns
> even at death was according to Magbobukwa because the freeborns do not
> believe that the Osus do have any soul to be saved, hence, there is nothing
> like the resurrection of the soul for them. Just as the case was with
> Whites and the Blacks in American and South Africa where the White sees the
> blacks as people with no history, no hope of life after death a blissful
> resurrection probably on the last day.
> .....
>
> As an ancillary to the above view, Onwubiko said in his book Facing the Osu
> issue in the African Synod that "it was the traditional Igbo religious
> belief that a person on whom the right of segregation was performed as was
> the case of the Osu was bound to be last in the life after death and
> thereafter would not attain the blissful state in the spirit world. This
> belief was very latent in the minds of the adult Igbos" (1993).
> ....
>
> Furthermore, Mabobukwa enunciated same of the rights enjoyed by the
> freeborns at death. According to him, when a man is pronounced dead, the
> relatives gather together and he will be lowered to the grave. Three days
> later, the buried rites begin, the following animals are provided:
> Ikenga Ewu (A female goat that has given birth)
> Agbogho Ewu (A female goat that has not given birth)
> Okemkpi (A he goat)
> Okokpa (A cock) (50)
>
> It is believed that when ever a person is buried with the enunciated items
> and several other ones, based on the culture and tradition, the person will
> be welcomed in the land of the dead. But since the Osus do not enjoy these
> rights during burial rites, thus, their spirits did not go well in the land
> of the dead. Thus, they will not take part in any thing that has to do with
> life after death.
> .......
>
> 3. *Chieftaincy  titles*
>
> One of the enormous social segregation between an Osu and the freeborns is
> prevalent in the case of making an Osu a chief or king over the freeborn.
> It is a sheer abomination in Igbo land till date to coronate an Osu or to
> crown any untouchable or slaves a king that will rule over the freeborns
> even if the person is the most eligible person for the seat in the
> community or land. The people would rather choose a mediocre or an
> unqualified person to rule them instead of seeing themselves being ruled by
> a known slave of the gods.
>
> Kenneth Ezeaguba in an interview made the following assertions "I witness a
> situation where a well educated man was acceded to the traditional
> chieftaincy title of grown town, this man is overtly overflowing with
> benevolence, integrity, dynamism, thus, he was very popular. But some
> people protested, claiming that he was said to be an osu and as such should
> not rule over the freeborn. They therefore chose a less qualified and
> unqualified illiterate as the rightful candidate"(interviewed at Owerri).
>
> 4. *Hospitality- GIVING A COLA NUT TO AN OSU*
>
> From the issue of making an osu a chief, also comes the issue of showing or
> giving cola nut to the osu. Due to the high esteem which the Igbo's held
> cola nut, it becomes a misdeed for a person to show cola nut to an osu in
> the presence of visitors or to give a cola nut to an osu who visited a
> freeborn
>
>  According to Jude Mgbabukwa, "the reason for this discrimination is
> because there is never a time an Osu is welcomed in the house of a Diala.
> In many social gatherings, by the time cola nuts are broken and eaten, an
> Osu is made to be aware that he is a stranger being manly tolerated" (48).
>
> Osu as at this time are regarded as inferior beings and as such should not
> be given a cola nut by the freeborns nor is it pertinent for an Osu to give
> cola nut to the freeborns.
>
> 5. *Summation of Discrimination*
>
> Children of the free born were forbidden to see the corpse of an Osu. An
> Osu could not be chief or a feasten of any village. If the corpse of an Osu
> was to be carried through the village of a Diala, palm frond was placed
> every where to warn the people that evil was in the air and a bad event was
> to happen. lf an Osu had a sexual intercourse with a Diala woman, the
> offending woman was to be dragged to the Osu to marry for free. Under no
> circumstances would a Diala run into the compound of an Osu even if it was
> raining or he was being chased with gun ormachete, if one did so, he or she
> automatically becomes Osu."
>
> *Extant Anti-Osu Discrimination *
>
> Those of those discriminatory practices still active are that on marriage
> and that on headship of communities.
>
> People on the Facebook groups against the osu system testify to that on
> marriage and the case of the  Omoude community I linked in an earlier post
> confirms the headship discrimination as active up till 1999. The village
> was seen as an osu community and so the rotational headship of the group of
> villages to which  it belongs to was denied it and its people brutalized
> into the bargain, so the story went:  the tragic story of the Omuode
> community in 1999<https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups=#%21msg/soc.culture.niger...>.
>
> *Further Questions from Chidi*
>
> (4) How are these manifestations handled?
> (5) Are these manifestations part of the hallmarks of the Osu agbaras?
>
> I would like clarification on these questions.
>
> Also, I am yet to observe a distinction known as 'osu agbara' in any
> source, apart from your summation, Chidi. Can you give any info that will
> confirm your summation?
>
> thanks
>
> toyin
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> On Wed, Apr 3, 2013 at 2:55 PM, OLUWATOYIN ADEPOJU <tva...@gmail.com> wrote:
> >  *   Response to Chidi *
>
> >        *Paradox of Spiritual Dedication and Service as Social Stigma in
> > the Osu System *
>
> > 1. *Spiritual Dedicand and Social Stigmatite [neologisms] *
>
> > '(1) Can servants of gods in Igboland be regarded as contaminated/
>
> > compromised humanity?
> > (2) Can Chukwu's(God's) representatives on earth; amadioha and others
> > condone being served by contaminated/compromised humanity?'
> > Chidi
>
> > The answer of collective Igbo cultural memory to this question is  YES.
>
> > The logic being that they are understood as contaminated in a way that  is
> > dangerous to other humans but is a consequence of their dedication to the
> > deity.
>
> > Francis Onwubuariri addresses this paradox in 'Appraising the Osu Caste
> > System in Igboland<http://www.frasouzu.com/Issues%20and%20Papers/Onwubuariri%20Francis.htm>
> > '
>
> > '...they can be given the sacred place of priest, they are still seen as
> > priests without power and prestige by the freeborn because they do not and
> > cannot command the respect or attract the admiration of the freeborns due
> > to their Osu stigma in the sight of the freeborns due to the fact that they
> > see themselves as inferior beings.'
> > ......
> > According to M. M. Green talking about making an Osu priest in his Book
> > Igbo Village Affairs, he made the point that "The Osu people looked up as
> > horrible and holy by the society do not necessarily make them into people
> > of authority, because of their anomalous
>
> ...
>
> read more »

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the "USA-Africa Dialogue Series" moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin.
For current archives, visit http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
For previous archives, visit http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue-
unsubscribe@googlegroups.com
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialogue+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.

No comments:

Post a Comment

 
Vida de bombeiro Recipes Informatica Humor Jokes Mensagens Curiosity Saude Video Games Car Blog Animals Diario das Mensagens Eletronica Rei Jesus News Noticias da TV Artesanato Esportes Noticias Atuais Games Pets Career Religion Recreation Business Education Autos Academics Style Television Programming Motosport Humor News The Games Home Downs World News Internet Car Design Entertaimment Celebrities 1001 Games Doctor Pets Net Downs World Enter Jesus Variedade Mensagensr Android Rub Letras Dialogue cosmetics Genexus Car net Só Humor Curiosity Gifs Medical Female American Health Madeira Designer PPS Divertidas Estate Travel Estate Writing Computer Matilde Ocultos Matilde futebolcomnoticias girassol lettheworldturn topdigitalnet Bem amado enjohnny produceideas foodasticos cronicasdoimaginario downloadsdegraca compactandoletras newcuriosidades blogdoarmario arrozinhoii sonasol halfbakedtaters make-it-plain amatha