USA Africa Dialogue Series - Child marriage: Evils that Senator do live with them

Child marriage: Evils that
Senator do live with them
 
KAYODE KETEFE
 
There are a number of things that are wrong with the 1999 Constitution, even as amended. The only amendments we have had so far relate to the electoral reforms and recognition
of National Industrial Court as a superior court of record. None of the much more important human rights issues like the enforceability of socio-economic
rights, women's rights, and removal of certain obnoxious provisions from the
constitution has seen the light of the day.   
Specifically, this writer has
written series on why many provisions of the constitution are violative of
women's rights and the imperative for amendment, but none of these, like the agitations of the larger civil society, has till date swayed the
lawmakers. For example, Section 29 of the constitution which makes provisions on renunciation of Nigeria's citizenship features in its Subsection 4 (b) a rather discriminatory proviso that "any woman who is married shall be deemed to be of full age".
The implication of this is that the
Constitution indirectly recognises child marriage as it bestows legal capacity
of an adult to any girl that is married even if she just nine years of age!
Besides, the provision is also discriminatory as there is no such presumption of adulthood for boys and thus this is contrary to section 42 of the same Constitution which forbids discrimination on the grounds of sex, among others.  The agitations of many human rights groups for the removal of
this obnoxious clause have hitherto been ignored.
Then, there came a ray of hope when
the Senate Committee on the Constitutional Review recently recommended the removal of the offensive section.  We also heard the cheering news that the Plenary Senate session had approved the expurgation of the section with 75
votes (which was even two votes more than the necessary two-thirds requirement,
that is 73 votes)
But all of a sudden, there was a
legislative abracadabra as the Senate revisited the issue and conducted fresh
voting where it could no longer obtain two-thirds necessary votes to effect the
amendment of the section!  We were told that the reason for this unusual
legislative procedure was that one Senator Ahmad Sani Yerima raised objection that the removal of the section would be against the tenets of Islam.  In
a nutshell, the Senate was stuck with status quo ante and could not
expunge the controversial proviso.
Contrary to the submission of Yerima
which actuated the Senate to erroneously beat a legislative retreat, many informed scholars on Islamic jurisprudence have insisted that Islam never sanctions marrying off under-age girls.
For example, a human rights activist
and the wife of the former Chief Justice of Nigeria, Mrs. Maryam Uwais, has
said there is nothing in Islam that supports the under-age marriage. She said
"Contrary to the position conveyed by the Senator from Zamfara, there is
certainly no unanimity of positions on such contemporary matters of social
interaction, within Islamic jurists or the various Schools of Thought. Surely
where there is 'silence in the texts' (i.e. primary sources) or lack of
unanimity as regards a particular practice, that opening allows for a society to determine for itself what is in its best interest (maslaha), in its own
context."
Human societies have over the age
treated practical existentialist contingencies with diverse responses. 
The culture of marrying off underage girls and polygamy are all emanations of the same cultural and sociological factors.  In the olden days when many
societies engaged in numerous adventures that were perilous to the male population like seafaring and  warfare, there invariably followed
disproportion in male-female statistics in such societies. Thus, a demographic
problem of superfluous female population ensued, necessitating expedient responses
like polygamy to take care of the extra women. The culture of child marriage
became an offshoot of polygamy after the latter had became entrenched in orderensure constant supply of marriageable material to support polygamy!
Today, modernity has helped many
societies to root out the accumulated behaviours spawned by past expediencies,but there are enough ignoramuses among us who would insist child marriage is our culture!
We now know that there are a lot of
physical, health, psychological and even economic reasons why young girlsshould not be married off at tender age.
 Many civilised countries
specifically stipulate the age of attainment of adulthood and the attendant capacity to marriage to be 18 or 21 while others leave it, supposedly to the informed and moral decision of their populaces.
Frankly, a girl undergoing pubertal
changes is ill-adapted to strenuous conditions of gestation and this often
cause physical and emotional damage to the young woman. 
The arising complications may also cause infant mortality, morbidity, the dreaded Vesicovaginal fistula or even death.
Besides, rushing young girls into marital responsibilities at a time they should learn a trade, get formal
education or be indentured to a vocation would result in economic deprivations of these youngsters later in life. Their counterparts who have made a more auspicious opportunity cost of their time would be economically empowered and
busy counting money while the deprived girls keep counting babies!
Certainly, history would not be fair
to those Senators who saw the opportunity to improve the lots of their
endangered compatriots and allowed it to pass by.

Sent from my BlackBerry wireless device from MTN

--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the "USA-Africa Dialogue Series" moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin.
For current archives, visit http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
For previous archives, visit http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue-
unsubscribe@googlegroups.com
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialogue+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.