Former US president's Decision Points contains anecdotes seemingly
lifted from books by several authors
Chris McGreal in Washington
Monday November 15 2010
The Guardian
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/nov/14/george-bush-accused-borrowing-memoirs
George Bush's memoirs were billed as offering "gripping, never before
heard detail" [http://crownpublishing.com/2010/04/25/press-release-
decision-points-by-george-w-bush-to-be-published-by-crown-
november-9-2010/" title="">"gripping, never before heard detail] of
his time in the White House.
Now it appears that Decision Points is not so much the former
president's memoirs as other people's cut and pasted memories.
Bush's account is littered with anecdotes seemingly ripped off from
other books and articles, even borrowing without attribution ? some
might say plagiarising ? from critical accounts the White House had
previously denounced as inaccurate.
The Huffington Post [http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/11/12/george-
bush-book-decision-points_n_782731.html%C2%A3s180908" title="] noted a
remarkable similarity between previously published writings and Bush's
colourful anecdotes from events at which he had not been present.
Bush borrows heavily from Bob Woodward's account Bush at War, which
the White House criticised as inaccurate when it was published in
2002. He also appears to take chunks from a book written by his former
press secretary Ari Fleischer.
Bush recounts a meeting between Hamid Karzai and a Tajik warlord on
the Afghan president's inauguration day, which he used as an example
of hope for the future of the country.
The former president writes: "When Karzai arrived in Kabul for his
inauguration on 22 December ? 102 days after 9/11 ? several Northern
Alliance leaders and their bodyguards greeted him at an airport.
"As Karzai walked across the tarmac alone, a stunned Tajik warlord
asked where all his men were.
"Karzai responded: 'Why, General, you are my men. All of you who are
Afghans are my men.'"
The Huffington Post notes that the account and the quote are lifted
almost verbatim and without attribution from a New York Review of
Books article by Ahmed Rashid.
Bush also lifts a quote from an interview John McCain gave to the
Washington Post on Iraq and then presents it as though McCain had said
it to him.
Even where Bush is present and is quoting himself, he appears to have
had his memory jogged by the accounts of others without finding much
to add.
Many of the borrowed lines are taken from Woodward's Bush at War, with
the former president's accounts of meetings bearing a striking
similarity to Woodward's.
Bush's publisher has suggested that only confirms the accuracy of
Decision Points. Others have suggested it is a reflection of two
traits the former president was often criticised for ? lack of
original thought and laziness.
Bush also quotes Woodward's writings almost word for word in places.
Where Woodward writes: "The second option combined cruise missiles
with manned bomber attacks," Bush says: "The second option was to
combine cruise missile strikes with manned bomber attacks."
And where Woodward's book says: "The third and most robust option was
cruise missiles, bombers and what the planners had taken to calling
'boots on the ground'," Bush says: "The third and most aggressive
option was to employ cruise missiles, bombers and boots on the
ground."
Bush manages to remember exactly the same shouts as Woodward from the
crowd at Ground Zero after the 9/11 attacks ? "Do not let me down!"
and "Whatever it takes" ? even though there must have been a slew of
them.
He appears to have borrowed from the memoirs of Fleischer in relating
an anecdote about a hospital visit to meet injured survivors of the
9/11 attack on the Pentagon.
Striking similarities between Decision Points and other writings,
uncovered by the Huffington Post website
- In Decision Points, Bush describes the inauguration of Hamid Karzai,
which he did not attend: "As Karzai walked across the tarmac alone, a
stunned Tajik warlord asked where all his men were. Karzai said: 'Why,
General, you are my men. All of you who are Afghans are my men.'"
- From Ahmed Rashid's [ (http://www.nybooks.com/articles/archives/
2004/feb/12/the-mess-in-afghanistan/)" title="The Mess in Afghanistan
in the New York Review of Books]The Mess in Afghanistan in the New
York Review of Books, as related personally to him by Karzai: "As the
two men shook hands on the tarmac, Fahim [the Tajik warlord] looked
confused. 'Where are your men?' he asked. Karzai turned to him in his
disarmingly gentle manner of speaking. 'Why General,' he replied, 'You
are my men ? all of you are Afghans and are my men ?'"
- From Decision Points: "The second option was to combine cruise
missile strikes with manned bomber attacks."
- From Bob Woodward's Bush at War: "The second option combined cruise
missiles with manned bomber attacks."
- From Decision Points: "The third and most aggressive option was to
employ cruise missiles, bombers and boots on the ground."
- From Bush At War: "The third and most robust option was cruise
missiles, bombers and what the planners had taken to calling 'boots on
the ground.'"
- Decision Points: "One man yelled: 'Do not let me down!' Another
shouted straight at my face: 'Whatever it takes.'"
- From Bush at War: "'Whatever it takes,' they shouted. One pointed to
[Bush] as he walked by and yelled out: 'Don't let me down.'"
- From Decision Points, quoting John McCain in a manner that suggests
he is talking to the then president: "'I cannot guarantee success,' he
said, 'But I can guarantee failure if we don't adopt this new
strategy.'"
-From an interview by McCain with the Washington Post in 2007: "'I
cannot guarantee success, but I can guarantee failure if we don't
adopt this new strategy,' he said.'"
guardian.co.uk Copyright (c) Guardian News and Media Limited. 2010
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the "USA-Africa Dialogue Series" moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin.
For current archives, visit http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
For previous archives, visit http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue-
unsubscribe@googlegroups.com
No comments:
Post a Comment