Tuesday, September 30, 2025

USA Africa Dialogue Series - Re: A question for Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju

 Great thanks Cornelius.

Christianity did penetrate some of those countries, from what I recall of China and India, and possibly established a powerful presence in India, and English colonization of India lasted much longer than in Nigeria, but these external powers did not achieve in those places the degree of  abandonment of endogenous spiritual culture evident in Nigeria.

One of the reasons could be the ancient traditions of widespread writing and reading in those Asian cultures.

You cant successfully demonize ancestor veneration in Confucianism, a central Chinese philosophy, because an entire library of Confucisn texts exist, spanning centuries.

You cant successfully present negative images of Buddhism because its philosophical principles, its historical development and its creative penetration into various aspects of Indian, Chinese and Japanese culture, creating some of humanity's greatest achievements, is obvious, through texts explaining their logic and the logic of this development, enabling appreciation of the principles of Japanese gardening, Japanese haiku poetry, Zen Buddhist aesthetics in Chinese and Japanese art, in Japanese architecture and Chinese martial arts.

You cant successfully disparage Yoga, possibly India's greatest export, because of its rich textual foundations and  its immense practical value, evident even outside its religious contexts, the case being the same for Chinese and other Asian martial atts, which are better understood against the background of Asian philosophies and spiritualities.

At the headwaters of much of Asian thought is Hinduism, represented by an awesome textual tradition surpassing anything created by Christianity and perhaps even Islam, cultural creativities generating some of the world's greatest dance, architecture and visual arts, and even inspiring comparisons with scientific theory, as in Fritjof Capra's famous The Tao of Physics, unifying Asian philosophies in terms of a Hindu image and using this in developing a  dialogue with modern science. 

Tibetan Buddhism, recondite as it can be in its imagistic complexity and theoretical sophistication, is richly represented by great texts of theory, practice and individual histories, enabling the torch to be carried anywhere in the world. I learnt of all these spiritualities and read some of their classics while living in Benin-City up till  2002.

In that same Benin, when seeking for works on classical African spiritualities and frequenting practically every bookselling environment in the city, I did not see any book on Benin spirituality. My exposure to the work of Norma Rosen on Benin Olokun spirituality in the academic journal African Arts, to that of Iro Eweka on Olokun, to Joseph Nevadomsky on the Obas coronation ceremonies, Daryl Peavy on Oguega divination  and others occurred through my first readily available Internet access through studying in England, and more recently, through Osemwegie Ebohon's books which he gifted me, but which I doubt if he had published in those earlier years when we ere in Benin together. I also have Tam Fiofori's fine book on the Obas coronation ceremony bought from him in Nigeria. I also encountered a powerful work on the Obaship at a bookshop in Lagos which i intend to buy later on account of its less than cheap price. The same applies to Charles Gore's likely landmark book on Benin shrines.

To what degree has the situation changed since 2002?

Is there any book that sums up endogenous Benin spirituality with the same comprehensiveness and sensitivity to the Benin language as Bolaji Idowu's Olodumare: God in Yoruba Belief, one of my most important books, and which I bought at Oba Market in Benin?

I would like to know about it.

Does any other endogenous Nigerian spirituality have such scholarly yet generally accessible books? What of  the equivalent of a Wole Soyinka innimitably  dramatizing  the imaginative power of Yoruba spirituality? Achebe and Christopher Okigbo have achieved something similar for Igbo thought but at less impactful level for various reasons,  including the relative slimness of their productions ,even though great works. When you add such a titan as Susanne Webger, one of the world's greatest spiritual writers, inimitable on Yoruba thought, the difference becomes clearer than ever.

But even the Yoruba textual achievement, great as it is, stretching from earlier periods to the Idowous, to Wande Abimbola's magnificent works on Ifa divination, to the more recent achievements of Akinwunmi Ogundiran on the history of Ypruba thought, to Toyn Falola's work in book after book exploring aspects of this system, to its explosion on the Internet, particularly social media, is yet a fraction of the Asian achievement in any of their spiritualities.

Happily, Nimi Wariboko, a master in the majestic presentation of Kalabari thought, has just published in Nigeria The Soul of Kalabari Culture, helping to bridge this  textual divide.

A good number of the best books on Nigerian spiritualities are published in the West, to which the scholars either migrated from Nigeria or where the Western researchers reside. These books are therefore hardly visible in Nigeria or expensive when visible.

I expect it is impossible to achieve a mass return to classical African spiritualties in Nigeria. The impact of Christianity and Islam is too strong, for various reasons, one of them again  being superior textualisation.

Anyone can pick up a Bible, almost anywhere, and read something for inspiration in it. In Southern Nigeria, access to varieties of Koranic translations in English is not so accessible but they also exist.

What books exist to read for inspiration even in the best textualized of Nigerian religions, classical Yoruba spiritualities?

Soyinka's Seven Signposts  seven stanza poem, published in Nigeria,  is pre-eminent but not well known. Akomolafe Wande has recently  brought out a series of  fa texts and accompanying meditations but the price would be prohibitive for many Nigerians. Another one he is working on promises inspiring texts from Ifa.

Wamde Abimbola's Ifa books are magnificent and Sixteen Great Poems of Ifa is cheap and readily available, but the inspirational  universe of such works is not as variegated as that of the Bible, for example, where the the soaring aspiration of the Psalms co exist with the homespun wisdom of Jesus parables, and the erotic force of the Song of Songs with Jesus ethical and spiritual teaching.

A similar ideational and expressive synthesis can be achieved in Nigerian sacred texts, but might have to be pursued through an elevation of creativity, bringing out the best texts, which also penetrate beyond doctrinal limitations, and perhaps amplifying them though recourse to artistic forms from their parent cultures, which communicate with a force different from written text.

A very different level of expressive force is achieved when one combines such visual symbols as Ghanaian Akan/Gyaman Adinkra, Nigerian Cross River and Cameroonian Nsibidi, Igbo Uli, Benin Olokun chalk art, Yoruba opon ifa symbols, in dialogue with visual texts.

Ultimately, textualities of Nigerian sacred cultures may best succeed within a pan-Nigerian and pan-African synthesis, as Ulli Beier achieved in African Poems, in which these spiritualites are presented as variants of the same system of thought and action, like the variants of Christianity.

We also need texts of people who live according to these spiritualities, inspiring emulation. Christianity and Buddhism are based on great exemplars. Muhammeds life is an inspirational template for multitudes. Saints are strategic for Hinduism and Catholic Christinity. Beyond such biogragies as that by the Ifa priest Yemi Elebuibon, and possibly by Ebohon, autobiography and  biography are still embryonic in classical Nigerian spiritualities.

Even when all that has been achieved  in terms of textulsation, the sheer social, educational, economic, political,  architectural  and artistic  impact of Christianity and Islam in Nigeria is so powerful that there can be no return  to the dominance, or even equality, of classical African spiritualities  unless perhaps a supreme calamity of some sort takes place to inspire that.




On Tuesday, 30 September 2025 at 23:47:48 UTC+1 Cornelius Hamelberg wrote:

Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju, 


With avid interest, for more than a decade now, we have followed your various peregrinations in the occult and allied subjects, mostly via Compcros , and right now, after your latest and in anticipation of Thursday's Webinar not on the theme Africanization of African Indigenous Religions, but on the theme " ReAfricanization of African Indigenous Religions" - slightly different from Re-Africanization of African Indigenous Religions, I'd like to ask you the following question which I have wanted to ask you almost every day over these many many years reading your discourses: 


The colonialists did not penetrate India, China , and Japan, with their Christianity (God forbid) and we are to suppose that is because these countries have very strong indigenous spiritual traditions, the bulwark of the resistance….


Given the smörgåsbord of religious traditions, not least of all the rich canopy of indigenous religious traditions in Nigeria , especially the indigenous religious traditions of pre-colonial Nigeria, how is it that Nigeria succumbed to that sort of mass conversion ( like the Khazars, the so called "Thirteenth Tribe") ?   


I understand that although it's a simple question you are going to give a longish answer.


I seem to remember Socrates was accused of introducing new gods


Al Islam has characterised pre-Islamic Arabia as the age of Jahiliyyah


BTW, do you foresee a cultural renaissance and a mass return to the roots in your neck of the woods in Nigeria ?


Ami Koita ( 1998) : Djiguy 


--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue+subscribe@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialogue+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/8a9f3391-1148-42b8-8b3b-cc438940ad35n%40googlegroups.com.

USA Africa Dialogue Series - A question for Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju

Oluwatoyin Vincent Adepoju, 


With avid interest, for more than a decade now, we have followed your various peregrinations in the occult and allied subjects, mostly via Compcros , and right now, after your latest and in anticipation of Thursday's Webinar not on the theme Africanization of African Indigenous Religions, but on the theme " ReAfricanization of African Indigenous Religions" - slightly different from Re-Africanization of African Indigenous Religions, I'd like to ask you the following question which I have wanted to ask you almost every day over these many many years reading your discourses: 


The colonialists did not penetrate India, China , and Japan, with their Christianity (God forbid) and we are to suppose that is because these countries have very strong indigenous spiritual traditions, the bulwark of the resistance….


Given the smörgåsbord of religious traditions, not least of all the rich canopy of indigenous religious traditions in Nigeria , especially the indigenous religious traditions of pre-colonial Nigeria, how is it that Nigeria succumbed to that sort of mass conversion ( like the Khazars, the so called "Thirteenth Tribe") ?   


I understand that although it's a simple question you are going to give a longish answer.


I seem to remember Socrates was accused of introducing new gods


Al Islam has characterised pre-Islamic Arabia as the age of Jahiliyyah


BTW, do you foresee a cultural renaissance and a mass return to the roots in your neck of the woods in Nigeria ?


Ami Koita ( 1998) : Djiguy 


--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue+subscribe@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialogue+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/56a6c9ed-797a-4f71-93d2-42a33eaa7636n%40googlegroups.com.

USA Africa Dialogue Series - Boosting Africa’s book publishing industry | CNN

--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue+subscribe@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialogue+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/CAGBtzfNCx0LAz0Xnykf_bX68W9K0mYzrQem%2Br_SiuF%3DFm%3DUPJA%40mail.gmail.com.

USA Africa Dialogue Series - European recognition of a Palestinian state is not an act of solidarity but a betrayal of Palestinian liberation ( A Voice Against the Two State Solution)

--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue+subscribe@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialogue+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/CAGBtzfMspvW%2BNR%2Bh%2BnPvthvsPcDhh5Z%2Bx8ZoxKKjVmSFsHqxew%40mail.gmail.com.

Monday, September 29, 2025

Lucre a partir de 130% do CDI

Você chegou e já tem mimo te esperando!
 ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌  ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌ ‌

Agora seu dinheiro pode
lucrar ainda mais!

E para aproveitar basta adicionar dinheiro na 99Pay

Olha só quanto esse presente
potencializa seus ganhos:

Você já saiu na frente, mas sua
lucratividade pode ser ainda maior!
Avance para o próximo nível com o

1.O usuário receberá o aumento de lucratividade de +20% do CDI válido por 30 dias a partir do dia 29/10/2025
2.O aumento de lucratividade segue as mesmas regras de qualquer outro aumento de lucratividade na 99Pay.
3.Válido para usuários selecionados. A 99Pay reserva-se o direito de descontinuar esta promoção a qualquer momento.

Você tá no lucro - 99Pay
Facebook Instagram X YouTube
99Pay Instituição de Pagamento S.A – CPNJ: 24.313.102/0001-25
Termos de Uso Privacidade

USA Africa Dialogue Series - Africa-Asia Indigenous Religions - A Comparison

You are invited.

Panafstrag International Lagos is inviting you to a scheduled Zoom meeting. 

 Topic: ReAfricanization of Africana Indigenous Religions Webinar Time: Oct 2, 2025 03:00 PM Africa/Lagos Join Zoom Meeting https://us06web.zoom.us/j/89313258556?pwd=DwNb9af8HcsQo65sz98dFnQx3wa0pK.1 Meeting ID: 893 1325 8556 Passcode: 935450 --- One tap mobile +13092053325,,89313258556#,,,,*935450# US +13126266799,,89313258556#,,,,*935450# US (Chicago) Join instructions https://us06web.zoom.us/meetings/89313258556/invitations?signature=715FWKq0dAHhCHiZbdolOuaQL26Z-Jy94Q206H5vnoc


--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue+subscribe@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialogue+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/CAATqZxXNP5qd%2BQGf9bM5-1Y%3DRXMpVaNxxvdJ-2FZpBv8b-NV8g%40mail.gmail.com.

USA Africa Dialogue Series - The Scholar as Disciple? Toyin Falola's Yoruba Metaphysics: Part 1                              

             The Scholar as Disciple?

     Toyin Falola's Yoruba Metaphysics

                            Part 1





                         Abstract

This essay explores the author's initial engagement with Toyin Falola's Yoruba Metaphysics: Spirituality and Supernaturality, situating it within Falola's broader oeuvre on Yoruba and African thought. 

Drawing from the book's preliminary sections, it examines Falola's methodical approach to unpacking Yoruba cosmology, emphasizing themes of mystery, human-spiritual interaction, and the universe as an ultimately incomprehensible yet engageable realm.

The piece compares Falola's work to other spiritual traditions, highlights a mapping of his writings on Yoruba thought in a movement from narrative-driven autobiographies to summative scholarship, examines challenges with the conceptualizations in the Author's Notes and outlines plans for deeper analysis in subsequent essays.

All pictures are by me.

Anticipation and Contextualization

I got my long awaited copy of Toyin Falola's Yoruba Metaphysics: Spirituality and Supernaturality on the 20th of September 2025, courtesy of the author, before its official September 23 release date.

I have been eager to read the book because I want to see if I can learn something new from it in a field in which I have some exposure.

Situating the Work: A Continuum in Yoruba Discourse

Could Falola package a topic already deeply discussed by Wande Abimbola, Ulli Beier, Wole Soyinka and others in a way that could validate a new book on a broad overview of classical Yoruba thought, an approach that has been so significantly outlined in previous discourse,  validation in terms of saying something unique or saying what is already known in a distinctive manner?

Contextualizing Falola's Cognitive Project

       The Evolution of a Cognitive and                 Expressive Process

I am also interested in the book as a landmark in Falola's progression towards building a comprehensive Yoruba  discursive universe, within the matrix of African Studies.

How will this book complement his discussion of Yoruba thought in "Ritual Archives", in African Spirituality, Politics, and Knowledge Systems: Sacred Words and Holy Realms, in Decolonizing African Knowledge: Autoethnography and African Epistemologies, in Esu: Yoruba God, Power and the Imaginative Frontiers, and his autobiographies A Mouth Sweeter than Salt and Counting the Tiger's Teeth, among other works of his exploring diverse aspects of Yoruba spiritual and philosophical thought and practice?

Writing as Thinking

Having reading the Author's Note, the preface and acknowledgements, want to respond to those sections  now rather than wait till I complete the book

Those segments are vital for appreciating the author's relationship with his subject, as he speaks there in more intimate and personalistic terms than I have seen him doing so far in his entry into his main text as represented by the introduction, a little of which I have read.

I am impatient to commence the scribal dialogue with Falola's work, particularly since the act of writing represents a process of thinking things through,  to adapt Anthony Appiah's perspective on philosophy.

Situating the Work: Walking, Flying and Running in Falola's Methodological Universe

      Walking: Systematic Exposition

"Thinking it through", the title of Appiah's book on philosophical method, is actually the central exploratory technique of Falola's book.

His goal is to painstakingly assemble the building blocks of his understanding of Yoruba metaphysics,  stating its fundamental premises, describing their logic, their rationale,  presenting his grasp of the views about the universe held by the knowledge community whose ideas he is describing, and possibly,  in the core of the book, examine the validity of those ideas.

In focusing on painstaking ideational organization, he may be described as walking, walking the reader linearly through his ideas.

       Flying: Narrative Mastery

That approach is different from the experiential narrative of growing up in close encounter with a representative of Yoruba metaphysics in its spiritual and supernaturalistic dimensions and observing how this complex of belief and action plays out in a time of crisis in a Yoruba community, the Agbekoya Revolt, this being Falola's progression in his accounts of his mentor Iya Lekuleja in A Mouth Sweeter than Salt and Counting the Tiger's Teeth,  a person who, most likely did not have the Western education to read what her young protege later wrote about her but who embodied, par excellence,  the endogenous Yoruba knowledge system he would grapple with in essay after essay, book after book, trying to map its contours, delineate its flesh and approach it's mystery.

The Iya Lekuleja sections of those autobiographies may be described as Falola flying, at the height of his conjunction of narrative skill and poetic evocation, imaginative concretization vivifying a linear narrative, stamping an indelible, embodied journey on the mind of the reader, in a manner rich with ideational force,  providing food for scholarship.

          Running: Intellectual and

          Imagistic Synthesis 

Falola "running" is evident in "Ritual Archives", in its fusion of the ratiocinative and the imaginative, the intellectual and the imagistic, as he shapes a vision of the essence of African sacred space as a physical and cognitive construct, in a manner, that, incidentally demonstrates  universal illuminative force,  piercing to the heart of the spiritual imagination.

Yoruba Metaphysics as an Exploratory Walk

In Yoruba Metaphysics the author seeks to make a summative statement of his relationship with the field,  not in an account of an individual and her communal network and role in an epochal historical event,  as with Iya Lekuleja, or a study of an aspect of the field, the field as perceived through a particular abstract concept, as with " Ritual Archives", or examining a deity, as with his essay on Esu in Esu: Yoruba God, Power and the Imaginative Frontiers or a particular institution of the knowledge system, as his chapter on the Ifa knowledge system in Sacred Words and Holy Realms, but to map the entire field, fleshing out its strategic ideational configurations and their interrelationships in shaping a unified world picture, addressing metaphysical ideas alone, without embedding them in a historical narrative examining the complex of social forces critical for the development of those ideas, as he does in Global Yoruba: Regional and Diasporic Networks.

The Scholar as Disciple: Embodying and Interpreting Tradition

Reading those opening reflections in the Author's Notes, the preface and the acknowledgements, I am reminded of Falola's ongoing tension between the scholar and the disciple represented by his various engagements with Yoruba spirituality and philosophy.

The scholar dissects, maps, and theorizes; the disciple lives, remembers, and embodies.

This dual orientation—between embodied knowledge and intellectual explication—  gives his multi-volumed project a particular richness.

Core Philosophical Framework

    Sensitivity to the Universe as  an                  Explorable Mystery: The Heart of                Endogenous Yoruba Thought

What strikes me most in the opening sections of the book is Falola's articulation of endogenous Yoruba thought as a sensitivity to mystery. 

He describes a universe that eludes full comprehension, yet invites engagement through the senses and the mind—where consciousness is both sensory and cognitive.

The idea of mystery suggests both a sense of helplessness within the embrace of the powers shaping the cosmos, as Falola puts it, as well as a sense of wonder at finding oneself within an immensity beyond the farthest reach of human exploratory powers but which nevertheless may invite exploration.

Such a sensitivity is both humbling and inspiring, evoking the littleness of the self yet energising its aspirational powers, a complex of attitudes that is one pf the richest responses to cosmic complexity and dynamism, as richly described by Wole Soyinka on the origins of drama in Myth, Literature and the African World, by Rudolph Otto on the numinous in The Idea of the Holy and Immanuel Kant on the Sublime in Critique of Judgement.

Yoruba metaphysics "serves as a framework for viewing the world, aclnowledging the existence of energies, forces, beings and other phenomena beyond human comprehension.

It evokes a sense of helplessness in the face of the powerful and unknown yet brings comfort in the understanding that there are methods and mindsets to comprehend and engage with these aspects" Falola declares ( xii ).

       Responding to Mystery

In the face of this immensity that sorrounds the human being, what does he do?

He reaches out to it. He organises his understanding of it in relation to his grasp of the universe he is aware of, including his knowledge of himself and his fellow humans.

Falola takes us into that organizational realm. Making a strategic contribution to the various ways of organizing the range of ideas constituting classical Yoruba thought, he sums up three fundamental ideas shaping this body of knowledge, here briefly presented with  subheadings by myself: 

1. Cosmic Incomprehensibility

We exist in a universe that is not fully comprehensible to us.

2. Spiritual Engagement

Humans can engage with [invisible] spiritual forces [ which coexist with the visible inhabitants of the universe].

3. Complementary Duality

These forces exist in an unseen or invisible realm, known as Orun...fantastical, magical, and challenging to grasp...[" the dwelling place of [ transitioned] ancestors and the origin of human existence before birth"] [ a zone] yet closely intertwined with the physical world...

. ..humans[ though] primarily residing in the physical world...are capable of interacting with the invisible realm under specific circumstances. (xii)

Comparative Philosophical Context

        Universal Resonances

A fine summation,  concise yet comprehensive, applicable to perhaps all classical African schools of thought and possibly to most spiritualities, and could be compared with Antoine Faivre's pioneering efforts in concise yet comprehensive mapping of Western esoteric cosmology through a similar list of ideas, indicating their interrelations ( "Western Esotericism and the Science of "Religions").

That balance between the challenges of total comprehension of the universe and engagement with the universe, between human physicality and semi- spirituality,  says it all for me.

       A Symphony of Mystery

            Christian

It takes me from my engagement with Yoruba and other schools of African thought to other spiritualities, summed up in the concept of mystery as depicted by Catholic theologian Karl Rahner in stating that the appreciation or understanding of the universe does not consist purely of expanding the boundaries of the known, whether in physical terms or beyond the physical, but in sensitivity to the difference between the known and a dimension of being that eludes full grasp, making the known equivalent to an island in a sea:

" The true system of thought  is the knowledge that humanity is finally directed precisely not toward what it can control in knowledge but toward the absolute mystery as such; that mystery is not just an unfortunate remainder of what is not yet known but rather the blessed goal of knowledge which comes to itself when it is with the incomprehensible One..The true system [ of metaphysical knowledge] is [ therefore] the system of what cannot be systematized."

(Leo Donovan, "Living into Mystery: Karl Rahner's Reflections on his 75th Birthday", America : https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2018/01/02/living-mystery-karl-rahners-reflections)

"In the ultimate depths of his being man knows nothing more surely than that his knowledge...what is called knowledge in everyday parlance is only a small island in a vast sea that has not been traveled.

 It is a floating island, and it might be more familiar to us than the sea, but ultimately it is borne by the sea and only beceauase it is can we be borne by it.

Hence the existentiell question for the knower is this: Which does he love more, the small island of his so called knowledge or the sea of infinite mystery? Is it the little light with which he illuminates this island-we call it science and scholarship- to be an eternal which will shine forever for him?

...when one begins to ask about asking itself, and to think about thinking itself...when one turns his attention to the scope of knowledge and not only to the objects of knowledge, to transcendence and not only to what is understood categorically in time and space within this transcendence,only then is one just on the threshold of becoming a religious person."

 (Karl Rahner, Foundations of Christian Faith, Darton: London, 1978, 22-23).

       German Secular Philosophy

" Two things fill the mind with ever new and ever deeper admiration and awe the more often and the more steadily they ate reflected upon: the starry heavens above me and the moral law within me".

(Immanuel Kant, Critique of Judgement)

       Ifa

"Ifa is about approaching everything as mysterious. Whether the mystery is great or small, Ifa invites us to marvel at its beauty as we grow in wisdom.

Mystery is encoded in all things that silently reveal how everything is connected in a dance around polarities which mutually affirm one another and move the world onwards.

Whether it is the mystery of life, creation, God, a plant, or a technical problem which we seem unable to figure out, we are touching Ifa.

It is about approaching all things and every situation with curiosity, beceause everything is encoded in mystery, awe and riddles.

Ifa is the key which enables us to decode these riddles and mysteries as they appear in our lives, in nature, in all realms of being and existence."

(Nicholaj De Mattos Frisvold, Ifa: A Forest of Mystery, Scarlet Imprint,2016, 7).

           Yoruba Orisa, Christian, Igbo

The yam is a primary symbol of mystery and its capacity for illumination. 

               Orisa

"The yam is dark and grows and rests in darkness; but it is white inside, where it is sweet sustenance.

Orisa Oginyon [ in Yoruba spirituality]  is the god of the yam, which means that he is the yam. And he is Obatala, the author of all inspired life. Through being the yam he is the sacred sustenance of matter; through being Obatala he is the transcendent light-dimension of that same matter.

               Christian

'...the transparency of the divine at the heart of a glowing universe; the divine radiation from the depths of matter aflame'[ Teilhard de Chardin] "

Susanne Wenger, A Life with the Gods in their Yoruba Homeland, Perlinger, 1983, 113, 138).

"Romanus Egudu ( poet of Igbo culture):

'I have dug it fresh,

this boneless flesh

of air, earth, warmth

and water, this

life out of the heart

of death..'

Visceral and sensous, entering deeper and essential associations, including the cosmic...extending the significance of the yam into a parable of the human condition, utilising lamguage that truly reflects the numinous essence of the experience, the social symbolism of the new yam and the metaphysical context both of its celebration, its seeding and maturation from decay".

( Wole Soyinka, Art, Dialogue and Outrage: Essays on Literature and Culture, New Horn, Ibadan, 1988, 321) 

Falola's outline of Yoruba metaphysics captures a similar profound sensitivity to mystery as the fundamental context of existence, pointing toward the incomprehensible, not merely the knowable. 

This perspective elevates Yoruba metaphysics beyond cultural specificity, situating it within a universal quest for meaning—a system of what cannot be systematized.

The Nature of a Human Being

Who is the person who finds himself within this mysterious cosmos and who tries to grasp  it as far as possible within its ultimate incomprehensibility?

It is a creature called eniyan, the Yoruba word for "person", implying the sentient composite, the animated physicality demonstrating certain unique qualities consrituting a human being.

What are those qualities? 

The human person shares in the balance of mystery and intelligibility, of matter and spirit, constituting the universe.

This embodied entity has its nucleus in something beyond conventional perception, something rooted in the world of spirit, ori, "the head", a non-physical head or nucleus embodying the ultimate potential of the self, " personalised and unique to each person, connecting humans to the spiritual and physical worlds, acting as a bridge to the supernatural forces,  which humans cannot fully comprehend," Falola states.

Navigating a universe which is more mysterious than comprehensible, within which even his own life is not fully under his control, the individual shapes his existence through choices made at the intersection of fate and free will, decisions contributing to shaping iwa, the unique identity of the individual, as "various physical and spiritual attributes interact and function within the human body...external, spiritual, and physical forces that shape and blend into a person" making the individual a "convergence point" constutiting "eniyan", the human person, as Falola sums up.

Human rationality is foregrounded in a description of "iwa", character as demonstrated through action. 

Iwa is itself fed by a complex of factors, most significant of which is ori, the head as a physical form containing the brain and its counterpart in the non-material essence of the self embodying the self's ultimate potential.

"Ori in ordinary speech means 'head'. The head is the physical dwelling place of the sacred principle.The brain, the most complex organism known, is in fact an ideal coordinating centre for the numberless sacred energies that are united in us"( Wenger, A Life with the Gods, 73)

Toward a Narrative Cosmology: The World as Story

I am also struck by the following in Yoruba Metaphysics:

" In Yoruba mythology, humans are portrayed as characters in a masterfully constructed story.

 The authors, superior beings, create these characters as having no awareness of their true purpose. 

 When the storytelling is skillfully executed, the characters influence the plot, and the plot, in turn, shapes the characters. 

Although the characters' paths are predetermined, their decisions and behaviour bring the narrative to life. 

If they fail to follow the plot, they are unable to justify their existence and consequently cease to be".

This is marvellous in the pathos involved in trying to develop a bird's eye view of the human condition, concluding on a note suggesting the scope of the human being's ignorance of the ultimate rationale of his existence even as he strives to shape reality within the possibilities available to him.

Ifa  cognitive networks are organized in terms of stories by diverse creators,  composed over a vast period of time, as suggested by the scope and variety of the texts.

Falola's life-as-narrative motif, a strategic contribution to Yoruba thought on account of its explicatory and applicatory potential,  is an image rich with possibilities for adapting the narrative imperatives of Ifa to explaining the totality of the human condition.

Falola's account of Yoruba thought as depicting the world as a narrative, in which humans are characters who influence the plot and the plot, in turn, shapes the characters, a narrative in which humans are both actors and authors,  gestures toward a narrative metaphysics—where the shape of the world is not fixed, but unfolding, participatory, and interpretive.

It also uggests a method of  mapping the distinctiveness of Yoruba thought's most prominent ideas on relationships between faith and free will, as different from those of Igbo and perhaps Kalabari thought, for example, on fate and agency,  as variants of the same structure of ideas defining African thought South of the Sahara, as I increasingly understand these synergies, akin to Falola's references to an "African thought system".

Between Cosmological and Individual Narrative

Falola's experience in composing and writing Yoruba Metaphysics  as described in its acknowledgements may provoke senstivity to the motif of life as narrative, a narrative unfolding in terms of the confluence of the known and the unknown, which the human being  navigates in ways shaping the outcome of the narrative, instigating questions of the balance between fate and free will, a pivotal concern of classical Yoruba thought and the thought of its proximate cultures in West Africa, from the Edo to the Kalabari, the Igbo and the Akan, among others.

Adapting the Yoruba adage of life as a river, a whirlpool emerged in the narrative river of Falola's life when he suffered a sudden stroke while driving at the time of writing the book. 

He survived the stroke and went on to an escalating program of writing and publication, including the completion and publication of some of his most strategic works, from Decolonizing African Knowledge: Autoethnography and African Epistemologies to  Global Yoruba: Regional and Diasporic Networks and now, Yoruba Metaphysics.

What confluence of factors came together to make him so fortunate? What is the relationship of such fortune to his own will to live and triumph, taking forward his varied consultations with Yoruba culture bearers and other catalyctic figures in his research, eventually resulting in Yoruba Metaphysics  and other books emerging after the stroke?

Resonances of iwa and ori radiate from this story, as eniyan proceeds on a dynamic motion through space and time.

          


A tree in the Osun sacred forest in Osogbo. Trees are understood as spiritual centres in endogenous Yoruba and endogenous African  thought.


Conceptual Challenges 

      Between Ethnicity and Cosmological            Allegiance in Yoruba Life

             The Marginalisation of Endogenous

               Yoruba Spirituality

The first sentence of Yoruba Metaphysics, from the "Author's Note" reads:

" To appreciate work on Yoruba metaphysics, readers who are not of Yoruba descent must make an effort to let go of their preconceived ideas, whether they are influenced by Western, Christian, Islamic, or any other beliefs".

But most Yoruba are Muslims and Christians. Is the world view described in the book not actually the perspective of a minority in Yorubaland?

I expect a significant number of Yoruba people in Yorubaland are acquainted with these ideas and they often occur in Yoruba films, but to what degree do they represent the faith allegiance of most Yoruba people?

Is it not more realistic to concede that what is being discussed is a spirituality and philosophy originating in Yorubaland, was developed in Yorubaland,  but lost its dominance in Yorubaland even as it metamorphosed into a pan-ethnic, multi-racial and intercontinental system of knowledge and practice, achieving a level of inter-class penetration beyond its current situation in Yorubaland?

During the recent show of power in Ilorin in Yorubaland by the Islamic leadership of the city, leaders who practice a politically absolutist form of Islam as an outpost of the Sokoto jihad which conquered Ilorin and imposed its brand of Islam, absolutism expressed in their forbidding the public practice of the endogenous spirituality of the Yoruba people, I read an advocate of the Ilorin stance, on Facebook,  challenging adherents of the endogenous religion with the question " can you point to anybody in political leadership [ politicians being a defining elite if not not the ultimate elite in Nigeria] who belongs to your religion?"

It would be hard to answer in the affirmative beceause endogenous Yoruba spirituality  is grievously marginalized even in Yorubaland, as demonstrated by the dominance of Christian and Islamic places of worship, the celebrity status of Christian pastors, the sheer demographic force of the Abrahamic religions and the potent association of Christianity with Western modernity,  the current face of human development in Nigeria and the foundation of its educational system.

The current Nigerian President, a Yoruba man and his Vice-President, to a number of the most prominent past and present governors in Yorubaland, are Muslim. The rest are Christian. 

I am not aware of any Nigerian politician who identifies as a practioner of any traditional African religion. It would be challenging to find public figures who do so.

In referencing the concept "Yoruba metaphysics " therefore, how realistic is it to describe it purely in terms of one faith community, and one that is marginal in its land of birth?

          Between Native Yoruba Spirituality                and Imported Religions

In discussing Chinese metaphysics, for example, one needs to address the indigenous spiritualities of Confucianism and Taoism but also the imported religion of Buddhism,  examining what is distinctive in Chinese Buddhism.

In exploring Yoruba metaphysics,  then, should both the endogenous and imported spiritualities not be addressed, on account of the range of their local and global impact, describing any distinctive qualities they demonstrate in Yorubaland?

What kind of world view, what metaphysical construct about the nature of reality enables one's to be a practising Muslim and an adept practioner of traditional Yoruba spirituality and even a leader of the Ogboni esoteric order, the best known of Yoruba esoteric groups, as I recently observed in Osogbo, in Yorubaland?

What metaphysical orientation is demonstrated in being an ardent Muslim and yet a leading seller of Yoruba herbal products, ritual artefacts and sacred arts, as I also recently observed in Osogbo?

Yorubaland has originated distinctive forms of Christianity, such as  Aladura and its derivatives, Cherubim and Seraphim and the Celestial Church of Christ, the beliefs and practices of which suggest a traditional religion/Christianity syncretism. 

What metaphysical identities do they represent?

What of  other churches?

What kind of world view, of metaphysical orientation,  can enable one be a prominent Methodist priest and yet be the writer of what for years has been perhaps the premier account of endogenous Yoruba cosmology  in English,  rich in weaving a compelling picture through the use of Yoruba oral traditions,  as exemplified by Bolaji Idowu's Olodumare: God in Yoruba Belief or Rowland Abiodun's life as a dedicated Christian Scientist and yet a foremost scholar of Yoruba metaphysics in its intersection with aesthetics and ethics, as represented by his Yoruba Art and Language?

Yoruba Christians have been particularly strategic in shaping Nigerian Pentecostalism, from as far back as the first Pentecostal church in Nigeria,  Christ Apostolic Church founded in 1941 and  led by Josheph Babalola, a deeply impactful figure in the explosion of the Pentecostal church in Nigeria.

What world view, what metaphysical orientations , are demonstrated by this continuity of influence?

In speaking of Yoruba metaphysics,  therefore, should one not identify and respond to the various metaphysical forms that are distinctively Yoruba, distributed across traditional Yoruba spirituality, Islam and Christianity?

In focusing on endogenous Yoruba spirituality, would it not be more appropriate to refer to it not simply as "Yoruba metaphysics ", as if it were the only metaphysical system that captures the allegiance of a good number of Yoruba people, but to use terms that reflect its distinctive character as one out of a number of Yoruba metaphysical forms,  terms such as "Traditional Yoruba Metaphysics", " Endogenous Yoruba Metaphysics ", "Classical Yoruba Metaphysics", " Orisa Metaphysics ( focusing on the deities of the religion, which include the ori, the spirit of the human being ) or Isese Metaphysics " ( focused on the community of believers)?

The non-ethnic name suggestions may facilitate appreciation of the fact that  endogenous Yoruba thought has gone beyond its ethnic origins,  operating as a pan-ethnic, trans-racial and intercontinental knowledge and belief system, a process Falola himself outlines in Global Yoruba: Regional and Diasporic Networks

    On the Universality of Metaphysics from      Religion to Science 

The recognition of various metaphysical orientations commanding the allegiance of significant demographics in Yorubaland is facilitated by an appreciation of metaphysics as a description of the nature of existence, of the structure and dynamism of the universe and humanity's place in it.

Every human action, even the very act of living from day to in society,  all institutions,  all knowledge systems,  from religion to science,  are based on a metaphysical foundation representing a picture of the world and the universe as a significantly comprehensible structure the logic of which makes life worth living, ensuring a regularity of experience that justifies human existence and activity. 

Yoruba Metaphysics, however,  at times treats the concept of metaphysics as identical with the kind of world view demonstrated by endogenous Yoruba thought,  as opposed to Western thought and science, which actually demonstrate their own metaphysical orientations.

             Forms of Rationality 

The idea of a metaphysical system implies a form of rationality, a kind of logic enabling the orderly structure represented by a metaphysics. That is the rationality Falola's book is devoted to demonstrating.

Hence the distinction made between spirituality and rationality in the third paragraph of the book is problematic.

It also runs the risk of perpetuating the Senghorian Negritudist fallacy of describing emotion or intuition as African and reason as Western.

 Studies in Yoruba forms of logic, from Hallen and Sodipo's work on hearsay "igbabo" as opposed to "imo", knowledge, in Yoruba thought, among other concepts they explore, to their work on aesthetics and ethics to Rowland Abiodun's elaborations on aesthetics and ethics in Yoruba thought demonstrate the rationality of endogenous Yoruba philosophy.

An Individualistic Strategy of Unifying Endogenous Yoruba Thought

Yoruba Metaphysics develops a strategy of integrating endogenous Yoruba thought, a strategy  that is Falola's contribution to the field.

In the Author's Notes he describes the text as primarily valid in presenting Yoruba thought as a specialised style of spiritually centred thinking.

What he actually achieves, however, is painstakingly outlining a ratiocinatively ordered cosmological scheme, at the intersection of intellect, matter and spirit, within the ultimate mystery represented by the cosmos.

Though his focus is on the Yoruba expression of these ideas,  its intra and intercontinental resonance may be readily identified, paradoxically highlighting the uniqueness of  the Yoruba expression of this global matrix.

 Conclusion: A Slow and Thoughtful Walk

In this opening installment of my response to Yoruba Metaphysics, I have given a very broad overview of aspects of the Author's Note, the Preface and the Acknowledgements.

I intend to continue by responding to the life-as-narrative motif in the Author's Note, exploring how it can sum up the author's perspectives in the Note, the Preface and Acknowledgements, the sections I've read so far,  exploring  its implications for understanding Yoruba thought as an existential and cosmological drama.

My goal in writing this review is not speed of delivery or immediate comprehensiveness of response.

I want a slow and thoughtful walk with the author, thinking with him and thinking with his help, perhaps developing new insights through his stimulation as I map his ideational progression. 

This approach reflects the very methodology Falola himself employs: the careful, systematic exploration of complex ideas that resist easy systematization.

 Like the knowledge system he studies, this review acknowledges that some insights emerge only through patient, sustained engagement with mystery.

Falola's vision of a Yoruba metaphysical system is not just a scholarly contribution—it is an invitation to reimagine the interface between thought, faith, and narrative.

 In taking up that invitation, I hope to think more clearly, see more deeply, and perhaps—through his stimulation—come to new insights of my own.

 



 

 

 

 

--
Listserv moderated by Toyin Falola, University of Texas at Austin
To post to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue@googlegroups.com
To subscribe to this group, send an email to USAAfricaDialogue+subscribe@googlegroups.com
Current archives at http://groups.google.com/group/USAAfricaDialogue
Early archives at http://www.utexas.edu/conferences/africa/ads/index.html
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "USA Africa Dialogue Series" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to usaafricadialogue+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To view this discussion visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/usaafricadialogue/CAGBtzfMKgPRnC3zW9Vceoy1H9%3DRHoYJ1GvPmtE5bJ9LW5fK6bw%40mail.gmail.com.
 
Vida de bombeiro Recipes Informatica Humor Jokes Mensagens Curiosity Saude Video Games Car Blog Animals Diario das Mensagens Eletronica Rei Jesus News Noticias da TV Artesanato Esportes Noticias Atuais Games Pets Career Religion Recreation Business Education Autos Academics Style Television Programming Motosport Humor News The Games Home Downs World News Internet Car Design Entertaimment Celebrities 1001 Games Doctor Pets Net Downs World Enter Jesus Variedade Mensagensr Android Rub Letras Dialogue cosmetics Genexus Car net Só Humor Curiosity Gifs Medical Female American Health Madeira Designer PPS Divertidas Estate Travel Estate Writing Computer Matilde Ocultos Matilde futebolcomnoticias girassol lettheworldturn topdigitalnet Bem amado enjohnny produceideas foodasticos cronicasdoimaginario downloadsdegraca compactandoletras newcuriosidades blogdoarmario arrozinhoii sonasol halfbakedtaters make-it-plain amatha